Thursday, 26 November 2009

Faith

Over the September mid-semester break, I went to the National Student Leadership Forum on faith and values. I was nominated by my college principal (and most flattered to be). I’m not entirely sure how I convinced my father to let me go, being that the whole “faith and values” stipulation, not to mention the fact that it is based on the idea of “servant leadership,” inspired by Jesus Christ, no less, made it sound like a bit of a Christian camp sponsored by the government, but the subsidy from the college probably helped. In any case, I’m extremely grateful I went – it was an incredible experience, and most rewarding.

The Forum consisted of keynote speakers at every meal, a variety of graces from different religions, much discussion about what it means to be a leader, our personal values, time in Parliament listening to speeches by K Rudd and Malcolm Turnbull (leader of the Opposition) about their own faith, community service, a Bollywood bling-themed party (complete with dancers trying to teach us how to shake them hips) and small, tight-knit groups, with whom we did, shared and ruminated everything. I was skeptical, I’ll admit, of the so-called “bond” we’d form , but we had so much fun (our community service was a “random act of kindness,” so we washed people’s windscreens for free at a service station) and I’ve kept in touch with almost all of them since, which is fantastic. The whole experience was invigorating; it made me remember what I want to do with my life: help people. Three speeches stand out in my mind. Two of them were by businessmen-made-charitable entrepreneurs, who espoused that it is OK to make money, because money is necessary in order to implement widespread and meaningful change. The third was a man called Dave Andrews, who devoted his life to changing other people’s. He opened up his house to the mentally ill and homeless; he moved to India at some stage to do the same, and was there when Mahama Gandhi’s wife was killed and got caught up in the riots. And he articulated some truths that can sit a little too close to home. He talked about various time in his life when he’d come to the rescue of others, or tried, and been beaten up for his efforts. He explained that “every act of violence is a victory over peace,” whereby inaction can be just as bad as action – to sit by while someone is suffering is just as bad as those who inflict it. Such compassion is rare, infectious and heartening.

One of the things it has made me think about, then and now, is my faith. If you’ve followed me even for a little while, you probably know that I’m a “raging atheist” (as Pepito puts it, so nicely.) But when it came my turn to share my story in our small group discussions I realised something. Just because I’m an atheist, doesn’t mean I’ve of “no faith,” as is the PC phrase. It just means my faith isn’t in some higher being; it’s in humanity. I still don’t whether I believe people are inherently good – I want to, but I don’t know if I can* – but I believe in the ability of people to make good, and that good will overcome. Which stems from or feeds my optimism that all will work out in the end. I resent the implication that I don’t believe in anything. Why does faith have to be religious?

I was talking this over with my friend K last week, and she raised an interesting point about religion (she, too, is an atheist, not that it makes a difference.) We were talking about religion, and whether the hope it provides, and the attempts at providing a guideline for morality justify it (in all its prejudice and discrimination) and she raised the question about morality for morality’s sake. That is, shouldn’t people want to do good because it is the right thing to do? Not for the sake of some afterlife, or greater power?

I was watching something the other day and I can’t remember what it was – it might have been John Safron, or it might have been a movie – and someone said “religion starts wars,” to which someone replied “no it doesn’t, it’s just an excuse, it’s not the cause.” Or something like that, I’m paraphrasing.


x

JAG

*Do people have a redeeming feature? I remember skimming through The Glass House, a thoroughly depressing but very engaging memoir. The young girl who writes and narrates the story asks how her mother can believe all people have good in them. What about Hitler, she says. Well, the mother answers, Hitler was good to his dogs.

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

I think we spoke about this a long time back, remember? Faith DOESN'T have to be religious -- if you can put your faith in something completely, say for instance, humanity, then who is to say that it ISN'T faith?

So well-written, JaG.


~Sharan

Pepito said...

Hear, hear JAG. I remember having a conversation like this with one of the catholic girls from my college, who was kind enough to tell me that she didn't think I was some sort of devil-child despite the fact that I am a raging atheist.

I actually checked, and according to my own bible (being wikipedia), I am not really an atheist, but rather an ignostic (or a theological noncognitivist), where I believe that every kind of thological opinion or position is too tied up in religious terms and concepts to allow for any successful debate about the nature of existence of God. Until we are provided with a complete and falsifiable definition of God, any question of his/her/its existence is meaningless. I like this view because it avoids the problem that all other religious stances get caught up in, being that one should still believe in God despite the fact that we cannot prove that he/she/it exists.

I rather like how Russell puts it in his teapot analogy (though it is perhaps a bit to scornful of religious practise): "If I were to suggest that between the Earth and Mars there is a china teapot revolving about the sun in an elliptical orbit, nobody would be able to disprove my assertion provided I were careful to add that the teapot is too small to be revealed even by our most powerful telescopes. But if I were to go on to say that, since my assertion cannot be disproved, it is an intolerable presumption on the part of human reason to doubt it, I should rightly be thought to be talking nonsense. If, however, the existence of such a teapot were affirmed in ancient books, taught as the sacred truth every Sunday, and instilled into the minds of children at school, hesitation to believe in its existence would become a mark of eccentricity and entitle the doubter to the attentions of the psychiatrist in an enlightened age or of the Inquisitor in an earlier time."

Pepito

Drop a tear in my wineglass said...

Something I wrote a long time ago:

My belief is that there is no Creator or Lord Almighty. Monotheism isn't accurate to me, and neither is the beliefs that belong to other religions such as Buddhism and Islam. However, I do respect all religious activities and am tolerant to all religions. I find it incredible that Christianity is so incredibly widespread and that the devotees are so amazing and committed to their religion after over 2000 years. I think that all Hindu ceremonies are magically beautiful and everything from the saris to the chants to the statues of Vishnu and other gods are amazing. The Muslim's pilgrimage to Mecca is like no other, and I truly and utterly find it compelling to see almost 4 million people wander and engage in a truly remarkable activity with the same goal. Religion is beautiful, the churches, the prayers, the ceremonies, the clothes, the people - all are beautiful.

However, I have not found a place for a God in my life. When I was younger, I used to pray, but it didn't really make me feel any safer, and eventually, I forgot to keep on doing it, and saw that my life turned out alright anyway. I'm not against religion or Gods, i simply have not found a need for them in my life and as I have grown older stopped believing that there is one. A divine power with control over all mortals actions and destinies and who bless them and grant them forgiveness for their sins is just too much for me. I prefer to live my life, and if it so happens that when I die, I have not sought redemption for my sins and I will be burned in hell for all eternity, then I'll just have to accept it.

However, our stay in the Philippines changed me: I understand now.

I'm not a particularly religious person, but everyone in my family in the Philippines is, so to be cordial and well-mannered, I attended church, listened intently to the priest, sang with everyone in a weird version of O Holy Night and didn't take communion in respect of the religion (I can't take communion since I'm not confirmed). The atmosphere in the church is so...spiritual. It really feels like there is something else in the room, something that caused all of these people to come together in this one room and form this...bond, of sorts, to each other. There is a part of the ceremony when you reach out to the two persons next to you and grab their hand and lift them up. People on the other rows come across the aisle and so there are these long rows of people holding hands, praying and singing (at x-mas time, we sang). The feeling of brotherhood, coherence, was overwhelming. There was another incident in the car on our way to a hot spring resort outside Manila. My grandmother started praying a prayer that would give us a safe journey. My mother and cousin who were also in the car responded to the prayer. I can't remember exactly, but it was something like:

Grandma: Oh Mary, mother of God, protects us and save us form the fires of Hell (I know, not the happiest prayer in the world)
Response: Mary, Save us, and relieve us of our sins

And my grandmother kept saying it maybe, 20 times, which eventually got kind of repetitive. Nevertheless, somehow, I felt safer. We were the only ones not praying, but after hearing the response, like, 15 times, I got it and I responded the last few times together with the rest. Somehow, I felt more comfortable and safer.

Drop a tear in my wineglass said...

In a weird way, I needed prayer and safety in the Philippines. I needed religion in a way. I felt almost useless without it. Back in Sweden, I see no room for it in my life. I don't feel compelled to go to church here, I don't feel like I want to either. I don't need it. In the Philippines, I did. I understand the purpose of religion, more so than I did before. I understand why people need God in their lives, I really do.

I still feel that my beliefs differ from the Christian ones, but in a way, I wouldn't feel worse by believing in God and His creations and ideas. To be honest, I still don't believe that there is an Almighty Creator, but a part of me kind of wants there to be. A part of me wants to know that whatever I do and wherever I go, whoever I'm with and whatever happens, there will always be someone who loves and cares for me.

Actually, there is. My mother.